ProgressiveAccountability.org » John McCain and Sarah Palin's Policies Will Hurt Seniors McCain-Palin Policies Raise Concerns For Seniors
• McCain believes Bush's privatization scheme is the only way to save Social Security
• McCain said Social Security "is a disgrace," denouncing the program as originally created
• McCain will begin taxing health care coverage provided by our employers, creating a $3.6 trillion tax increase
• McCain has voted AT LEAST 28 TIMES to cut, restrict, or underfund Medicare
• McCain has voted AT LEAST 28 TIMES against Medicare prescription drug coverage
• McCain prioritized tax cuts for the wealthy over saving Medicare
McCain Believes Social Security "Is A Disgrace"
McCain Said Social Security As It Was Originally Set Up "Is A Disgrace." At an event on July 7, 2008, Senator McCain said, "Americans have got to understand that we are paying present day retirees with the taxes paid by young workers in America today. And that's a disgrace. It's an absolute disgrace, and it's gotta be fixed." [Town Hall Meeting, Denver Colorado, 7/7/08]
- Washington Post: If Social Security "Is A Disgrace, It Has Been One Since Social Security Was Created." The Washington Post reported, "John McCain once said economics was not his strong suit. Well, today, Social Security became a problem for the presumptive Republican nominee, too. In remarks at a town hall meeting in Denver Monday, which are only now catching up to him, the presumptive Republican nominee laid out what he likes to call 'a little straight talk.' 'Americans have got to understand that we are paying present-day retirees with the taxes paid by young workers in America today. And that's a disgrace. It's an absolute disgrace, and it's got to be fixed,' he said. If that payment system is a disgrace, it has been once since Social Security was created during the Great Depression. For as long as the popular program has existed, today's workers have paid the benefits of today's retirees." [Washington Post, 7/9/08, emphasis added]
McCain Will Privatize Social Security In Order To "Fix" The System
McCain Said Privatization Was The Only Way To Save Social Security. During a 2004 speech in New Hampshire, John McCain was asked, "Will privatizing Social Security be a priority for you going forward?" McCain said, "Without privatization, I don't see how you can possibly over time make sure that young Americans are able to receive Social Security benefits." [C-Span, "Road To The White House" via YouTube.com, accessed 6/18/08]
McCain Supports Privatization. According to his website, www.JohnMcCain.com, "John McCain supports supplementing the current Social Security system with personal accounts." [McCain Website, accessed 5/14/08]
WSJ: McCain Backs Bush's Plan for Privatization As "Main Solution To Reducing Obligations For Social Security." As reported by the Wall Street Journal, "[McCain] also backs President Bush's proposal for private retirement accounts as the main solution to reducing taxpayer obligations for Social Security." [Wall Street Journal, 3/26/08]
McCain Said "Private Savings Accounts Work." While appearing with President Bush in Tucson, Arizona in 2005, McCain said, "Private savings accounts work. They have been proven to work not only in America but all over the world, and we ought to really strongly support it." [Presidential speech in Tucson, Arizona, 3/21/05; Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents]
McCain Defended Bush Plan, Said "Personal Savings Accounts Are Workable And Have Worked In Other Countries." McCain said, "Well, I think the president wants to take a comprehensive approach to start with, but, second of all, these personal savings accounts are workable and have worked in other countries. They could pay a much greater return than the present 1.8 to 2 percent. We members of Congress and federal employees can invest our money into these five different — and we're doing fine, between seven and nine percent return. The president is willing to look at a comprehensive fix" [CNN, "Inside Politics," 3/03/05]
McCain Would Consider Benefit Cuts, Tax Increases For Social Security Fix
McCain's Top Economic Advisor Said Social Security Benefits Must be Cut. The Nation reported: "McCain's economic aide, Douglas Holtz-Eakin, poured a little more oil on the fire by explaining that Social Security benefits must be cut to keep the system solvent. 'You can't keep promises made to retirees,' Holz-Eakin said." [The Nation, 3/4/08]
McCain Said Increasing Payroll Taxes Was An Option. According to the Sioux City Journal, McCain "said raising the payroll tax that goes into Social Security is a last resort," but didn't rule it out as an option. [Sioux City Journal, 10/26/07]
McCain Said Lifting Cap on Payroll and Social Security Tax "Should Be Something That's On The Table." In 2005, when asked about the possibility of lifting the cap so that people would pay payroll tax, Social Security tax, not just on the first $90,000 of income, but perhaps even higher, McCain answered, "As part of a compromise I could, and other sacrifices, because we all know that it doesn't add up until we make some very serious and fundamental changes. … So my answer is, if everything's on the table, certainly that should be something that's on the table because, according to polls I've seen, that's the one thing that most Americans agree is probably a viable option, but not by itself but with other changes that need to be made. And if we don't, then we might as well say, 'Look, it's not going to change.'" [NBC, 2/20/05]
McCain Voting Record Jeopardizes Social Security
McCain Voted In Favor Of Establishing Private Social Security Accounts. In 1998, McCain voted for an amendment that expressed the sense of the Senate that any federal budget surplus should be used to reduce the Social Security payroll tax and to establish personal retirement accounts. The measure passed 50-48. [SCR 86, Vote #77, 4/2/98]
McCain Voted To Create Personal Retirement Accounts. In 1998, McCain voted for legislation expressing that the budget surplus can be used to establish a program of personal retirement accounts for working Americans to reduce unfunded liabilities of Social Security program. [SCR 86, Vote #56, 4/1/1998]
McCain Voted Against Increasing Social Security Survivor's Benefit In 2000, McCain voted against an amendment that would increase the Social Security survivors' benefit to at least 75 percent of the combined benefits of the husband and wife. It also would allow workers to take time off to raise a child or care for a dependent relative, and dedicate interest savings from paying off the national debt to Social Security. The amendment failed 42-54. [H.R. 8, Vote #192, 7/14/00]
McCain Prioritized Tax Cuts Over Guaranteeing Social Security for Future Generations. In 2005, McCain voted against an amendment that would make the consideration of new tax cuts or net mandatory spending that would increase the deficit subject to a 60-vote point of order unless Congress restored the solvency of Social Security for 75 years. The amendment fell 45-55. [S.C.R. 18, Vote #47, 3/15/05]
McCain Opposed Protecting Social Security
McCain Voted Against Protecting The Social Security Trust Fund
McCain Voted Against Protecting The Social Security Trust Fund. In 2004, McCain voted against a measure that would have created a point of order against any direct spending or revenue legislation that increases on-budget deficit in any fiscal year until budget is balanced without counting Social Security surplus. The measure fell 46-51. [SCR 95, Vote #33, 3/9/04]
McCain Voted Against Efforts To Provide Safeguards For Social Security Surpluses. In 2000, McCain voted against a measure that would provide procedural obstructions to any measure which decreases Social Security surpluses below levels established in resolution or that amends Budget Act to allow Social Security surpluses to be decreased below the levels established in resolution. The amendment fell 44-56. [SCR 101, Vote #65, 4/7/00]
McCain Voted Against Requiring A 3/5 Majority Vote In The Senate For Any Bill Pertaining To Social Security. In 1998, McCain voted in opposition to a measure that would provide a supermajority point of order against any change in the off-budget status of social security. The measure fell 42-58. [SCR 86, Vote #58, 4/1/98]
McCain Health Care Plan Threatens Americans' Coverage
McCain's Plan Would Remove Incentives For Employers To Provide Health Insurance. According to the New York Times, McCain's health care plan calls "for eliminating the tax breaks that currently encourage employers to provide health insurance for their workers." They added that, "His proposal to move away from employer-based coverage was similar to one that President Bush pushed for last year, to little effect." [New York Times, 4/30/08]
McCain's Plan Would Force Patients To "Buy Health Insurance On Their Own." McCain's healthcare plan is an attempt to force patients to "buy health insurance on their own instead of receiving it from their employers." [New York Times, 5/1/08]
McCain's Plan "Would Seek To Lure Workers Away From Their Company Health Plans." While describing the health care plan proposed by John McCain, The Washington Post wrote, "McCain's prescription would seek to lure workers away from their company health plans." McCain would provide families with a $5,000 tax credit to purchase their own health insurance on the free market. [Washington Post, 4/30/08]
McCain Would Classify Employer-Provided Insurance As Taxable Income; Would Equal A $3.6 Trillion Tax Increase. McCain's attempt to eliminate the employer-based health care system would include classifying employer-provided insurance as taxable income. McCain's chief economic advisor, Douglas Holtz-Eakin said that the new tax would raise an estimated $3.6 trillion in revenues. [Associated Press, 4/29/08; emphasis added]
- Despite "No Taxes" Pledge, Admitted His Health Care Plan Would "Have The Effect" Of Increased Taxes. The New York Times wrote, "Though Senator John McCain has promised to not raise taxes, his campaign acknowledged Wednesday that JPthe health plan he outlined this week would have the effect of increasing tax payments for some workers, primarily those with high incomes and expensive health plans." Holtz-Eakin said that, for some, McCain's health care plan would be unable to cover the costs associated with the elimination of the employer-based system. [New York Times, 5/1/08]
- "Anyway You Cut It, If You Make Health Benefits Subject To Taxation, That's A Tax Increase." McCain has asserted that his plan to tax employer-provided health coverage is consistent with his "no taxes" pledge. "Some scholars say otherwise. 'Anyway you cut it, if you make health benefits subject to taxation, that's a tax increase,' said Jonathan B. Oberlander, a political scientist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. 'You can argue with lots of merit that it's a responsible increase, that it takes away an inequitable exclusion, but it's still a tax increase.'" [New York Times, 5/1/08]
- McCain: "I'm Sure The People That Had To Pay It, Whether They Called Them Bananas, They Still Had To Pay $730 Million Extra." During the Republican primary battle, McCain often criticized Mitt Romney for increasing taxes while he was governor. Romney, referred to them as "fees," but McCain insisted that it amounted to a tax increase. During a debate, McCain said, "He called them 'fees.' I'm sure the people that had to pay it, whether they called them bananas, they still had to pay $730 million extra." [CNN, Republican Debate at the Reagan Library, 1/30/08]
McCain's Plan "Could Be Problematic" For Seniors And Those With Preexisting Conditions. While reporting on McCain's plan to force Americans to purchase their own insurance, The Wall Street Journal wrote, "That could be problematic for older people and those in poor health, who are routinely denied health insurance on the individual market, or charged very expensive premiums, because insurance companies know they will be costly to care for." Karen Pollitz of the Georgetown University said that, "those with cancer, diabetes, heart disease, HIV, epilepsy and other more serious problems are rejected outright 99% of the time." [Wall Street Journal, 4/30/08]
- McCain's Plan Could Allow Insurers To Exclude Patients With Preexisting Conditions. According to a report published by the Center for American Progress Action Fund, "Employers do not charge workers or their families different premiums based on their age, gender, health status, or health history. They also offer equal benefits and choices of plans. The individual market, however, plays by different rules. Individual insurers in most states can exclude people with pre-existing conditions directly by denying them coverage or indirectly by charging them exorbitant premiums." [Center for American Progress Action Fund, 4/29/08]
- People With Serious Health Problems Face Premiums That Are 43% To 50% Higher. According to a report published by the Center for American Progress Action Fund, "Compared to people in excellent health, premiums in the individual market are 43 to 50 percent higher for people with major health problems." [Center for American Progress Action Fund, 4/29/08]
McCain's $5,000 Credit Would Not Cover The Average Family's Health Insurance. Many health policy experts say that McCain's plan would not cover health insurance costs for the average American family. The Kaiser Family Foundation stated that the average cost of an employer-funded family insurance plan is $12,106, far more than McCain's proposed $5,000 tax credit. The New York Times quoted Paul B. Ginsburg from the Center for Studying Health System Change as saying, "For a lot of people, the tax credits he's talking about would not be enough to afford coverage." [New York Times, 4/30/08]
McCain's Plan Could Force Middle-Income Workers To Pay More For Health Coverage. In an article analyzing McCain's health care plan, the New York Times noted that, "analysts point out that middle-income workers with conventional coverage could conceivably pay more in regions where insurance costs are high. Over time, that might depend on how the tax credits are adjusted for inflation, a detail Mr. McCain has not discussed." [New York Times, 5/1/08]
McCain's Deregulation Plan Could Result In Insurance Companies Offering Fewer Patient Services. According to the New York Times, "McCain also wants to let people buy insurance from companies in other states, so they could shop for cheaper plans. That could lead some insurers to relocate from highly regulated states to states that would allow them to cover fewer services." [New York Times, 4/30/08]
McCain's Plan Won't "Make A Dent In The Number Of Uninsured Americans." While describing McCain's attempt to end the employer-based health care system, The Wall Street Journal wrote, "The plan isn't expected to make a major dent in the number of uninsured Americans, and questions remain about how the plan would help older, sicker people who can't find insurance on the open market." [Wall Street Journal, 4/30/08]
McCain Has A Dismal Record On Medicare
McCain Has Voted To Cut, Restrict, Or Underfund Medicare At Least TWENTY-EIGHT Times. [S. 1932, Vote #363, 12/21/05; S. 1932, Vote #303, 11/3/2005; S. 1, Vote #253, 6/26/03; S. 1, Vote #247, 6/26/03; SCR 23, Vote #89, 3/25/03; HJR 2, Vote #21, 1/23/03; H.J.R. 2, Vote #21, 1/23/03; H.C.R. 83, Vote #73, 4/5/01; HCR 83, Vote #73, 4/5/01; S.C.R. 86, Vote #53, 4/1/98; H.C.R. 178, Vote #156, 5/23/96; H.C.R. 178, Vote #159, 6/13/96; H.R. 2491, Vote #584,11/17/95; H.R. 2491, Vote #556, 10/27/95; H.C.R. 67, Vote #296, 6/29/95; S.C.R. 13, Vote #232, 5/25/95; S. 1357, Vote #499, 10/26/95; HCR 178, Vote #159, 6/13/96; HCR 178, Vote #156, 5/23/96; S 1357, Vote #524, 10/27/95; S 1357, Vote #499, 10/26/95; HCR 67, Vote #296, 6/29/95; SCR 13, Vote #232, 5/25/95; SCR 13, Vote #218, 5/25/95; S.C.R. 13, Vote #173, 5/22/95; H.R. 2491, Vote #584, 11/17/95; H.R. 2491, Vote #556, 10/27/95; S. 1932, Vote #363, 12/21/05; SCR 13, Vote #173, 5/22/95]
McCain Voted To Restrict Access To Medicare At Least TWO Times. [S 947, Vote #112, 6/24/97; S 947, Vote #115, 6/25/97]
- McCain Voted To Raise The Medicare Eligibility Age From 65 to 67. In 1997, McCain voted in favor of raising the eligibility age for receiving Medicare from 65 to 67 with the change being phased in between 2003 and 2027. The motion passed 62-38. [S 947, Vote #112, 6/24/97]
McCain Voted Against Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage At Least TWENTY-EIGHT Times. [S 1, Vote #262, 6/26/03; S1, Vote #259, 6/26/03; S 1, Vote #254, 6/26/03; S 1, Vote #253, 6/26/03; S1, Vote #250, 6/26/03; S 1, Vote #240, 6/24/03; S 1, Vote #239, 6/24/03; S 1, Vote #236, 6/24/03; S 1, Vote #234, 6/24/03; S 1, Vote #229, 6/19/03; S 1, Vote #227, 6/18/03; S. 1932, Vote #363, 12/21/05; S 1932, Vote #302, 11/3/05; S 1054, Vote #159, 5/15/03; SCR 23, Vote #89, 3/25/03; SCR 23, Vote #82, 3/25/03; SCR 23, Vote #63, 3/20/03; S 812, Vote #199, 7/31/02 ;S 812, Vote #187, 7/23/02; S 812, Vote #186, 7/23/02; S 812, Vote #182, 7/18/02; HCR 83, Vote #66, 4/3/01; HCR 83, Vote #65, 4/3/01; HR 4810, Vote #206, 7/17/00; HR 8, Vote #186, 7/13/00; HR 4577, Vote #144, 6/22/00; SCR 101, Vote #52, 4/5/00; S 1429, Vote #231, 7/29/99]
- McCain Voted Against Lowering Prescription Premiums for Medicare Recipients. In 2003, McCain voted against an amendment that would authorize $2.4 billion a year for four years to lower premiums for enrollees in a Medicare prescription drug benefit plan. The amendment failed 39-59. [S 1, Vote #254, 6/26/03]
- McCain Voted Against Ensuring Drug Coverage for Cancer Patients. In 2003, McCain voted against an amendment that would prevent any loss of drug coverage for beneficiaries with cancer before catastrophic care begins. The motion to table the amendment passed 54-44. [S1, Vote #250, 6/26/03]
- McCain Voted Against Guaranteeing Affordable Prescription Premiums for Seniors. In 2003, McCain voted against an amendment that would limit any increase in prescription drug premiums to 10 percent of the national average monthly prescription drug premium. The amendment failed 39-56. [S 1, Vote #229, 6/19/03]
McCain Has Voted Against Ensuring Medicare's Future By Opposing Efforts To Extend Its Solvency At Least NINE Times. [H.R. 1836, Vote #137, 5/22/01; H.R. 4577, Vote #162, 6/29/00; S. 1429, Vote #228, 7/29/99; H.C.R. 68, Vote #84, 4/13/99; S.C.R. 20, Vote #66, 3/25/99; S.C.R. 20, Vote #61, 3/24/99; S.C.R. 20, Vote #59, 3/24/99; S. 947, Vote #125, 6/25/97; S. 947, Vote #124, 6/25/97]
McCain Voted Against Using the Budget Surplus to Extend Medicare's Solvency. In 1999, McCain voted against including provisions that would allow targeted tax relief for low- and moderate-income working families and that would reserve a sufficient portion of projected non-Social Security surpluses to extend Medicare's solvency significantly before any budget surpluses could be used to give tax breaks that mostly benefited wealthy Americans. The motion to table passed 54-45. [H.C.R. 68, Vote #84, 4/13/99]
McCain Prioritized Tax Cuts for the Wealthy Over Saving Medicare. In 1999, McCain voted to kill an amendment that would strike the Budget Resolution's proposed $320 billion in tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans over ten years and direct the funds to Medicare or debt reduction. The motion to table passed 53-46. [S.C.R. 20, Vote #66, 3/25/99]
McCain Voted Against Protecting Social Security and Medicare. In 1999, McCain voted against an amendment that would reserve 40 percent of the non-Social Security budget surplus to ensure the solvency of Medicare through 2020 and would establish a Senate point of order against spending money reserved for Social Security or Medicare. The amendment failed 45-54. [S.C.R. 20, Vote #61, 3/24/99]
McCain Has A Record Of Opposing Access To Care For The Uninsured
McCain Voted To Deny Basic Health Protections To More Than 100 Million Americans. In 1999, McCain voted for an amendment which stated findings that attempted to justify excluding 113 million Americans from patient protection legislation and supported enacting legislation that affects only 48 million self-insured Americans; and speeds previously scheduled deductibility of health insurance costs of self-employed individuals. The amendment passed 53-47. [S 1344, Vote #202, 7/13/99]
McCain Opposed Expanding COBRA Coverage to Retirees. In 2000, McCain voted against an amendment that would have expanded COBRA coverage to include retirees whose employer-sponsored health care coverage was terminated. The amendment failed 30-68. [HR 4810, Vote #202, 7/17/00]
McCain Voted Against Increasing Benefits For Children With Special Needs In The Social Security Act. In 1997, McCain voted to table an amendment that would revise the Social Security Act to include additional benefits for children with special needs, including mental health services, as well as physical, speech and language therapy. The motion to table passed 57-43. [S 947, Vote #128, 6/25/97]
McCain Voted Against Families Who Rely On HMO-Based Health Coverage
McCain Voted Against Requiring Continued Care For HMO Patients. In 1999, McCain voted against an amendment that would require HMOs to provide at least a 90-day extension of coverage for patients undergoing treatment if their plan changes or their doctor's contract with the plan is terminated. The amendment failed 48-52. [S 1344, Vote #209, 7/15/99]
McCain Voted Against Prohibiting HMOs From Interfering In Decisions Between Doctors And Their Patients. In 1999, McCain voted for an amendment that prevented the establishment of protections to prevent inappropriate interference between health care professionals and their patients. The amendment passed 54-46. [S 1344, Vote #208, 7/15/99]
McCain Voted Against Holding HMOs Accountable For Denial Of Treatment Decisions That Lead To Death Or Injury. In 1999, McCain voted to prohibit patients from suing in state courts for damages if they are harmed by an HMO plan's denial of treatment. The amendment to strike language allowing patients to sue passed 53-47. [S 1344, Vote #206, 7/15/99]
McCain Opposes Health Care For Kids
McCain Opposed Extending Coverage To Uninsured Children. On October 31, 2007, after President Bush vetoed the first SCHIP reauthorization, McCain again opposed expanding SCHIP to millions of additional children. He voted against a motion to invoke cloture and bring the reauthorization forward for a vote before the Senate. The motion passed 62-33. [H.R. 3963, Vote #401, 10/31/07]
McCain Opposed Reauthorizing SCHIP And Providing Insurance For Millions Of Uninsured Children. In August 2007, McCain voted against passage of H.R. 976, which would have reauthorized the State Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP). According to Knight Ridder, "The Senate proposal would provide coverage to 3.2 million" uninsured children and renew coverage for the 6 million children already covered by the program. The legislation passed 68-31. [H.R. 976, Vote #307, 8/2/07; Knight Ridder, 8/2/07]
- McCain Opposed SCHIP Because It Would Cover Too Many Children. McCain not only voted against SCHIP, he went to the Senate floor to argue against covering millions of additional children, arguing "the program has expanded beyond what Congress first intended. In some cases, SCHIP coverage has been extended to middle-income children." [Congressional Record, 8/2/07]
- McCain: Covering Uninsured Children Is Too Expensive. According to the Washington Post, McCain said, "[what] was supposed to be for low- income Americans is now up to 400 percent of the poverty level, just like the Medicare prescription drug program, an unfunded liability." [Washington Post, 10/10/07]
- McCain's Looked Out For Tobacco Industry Over American Children. The New York Times reported, "Senator John McCain opposes the so-called S-Chip bill to expand children's health care coverage, in part because it widely expands the eligibility criteria and would cost some $35 billion… But what really sets him off is the way Congress proposes to finance the measure, which President Bush vetoed and is facing a veto override vote: an added tax on cigarettes." [New York Times, 10/16/07]
- McCain Then Skipped Vote On Passage Of The Bill. After clearly registering his opposition to the SCHIP reauthorization by voting against the cloture motion, McCain skipped the vote on passage of the legislation. The bill passed 64-30. The Kansas City Star reported the bill would "provide health insurance to an additional 4 million lower-income children." [H.R. 3963, Vote #403, 11/1/07; Kansas City Star, 11/2/07]
McCain Voted Against Expanding Health Care For Pregnant Women. In 2003, McCain voted against allowing states to expand the States' Children's Health Insurance Program to include low-income pregnant women. He also voted against authorizing $10 million for a program to educate public health organizations, providers and the public about the availability and effectiveness of emergency contraceptives; allow state public health agencies to apply for grants for further programs; require private health plans to cover prescription contraceptives and related medical services; and require hospitals to make emergency contraceptives and information about them available to rape victims. [S 3, Vote #45, 3/11/03]
McCain Voted Against Allowing Uninsured Parents To Enroll In The Same Plans As Their Children. In 2000, McCain voted against an amendment would allow states to expand coverage under the Medicaid and State Children's Health Insurance Programs (S-CHIP) to the parents of the children enrolled in the program. The amendment failed 51-47. [HR 4810, Vote #204, 7/17/00]
McCain Skipped A Vote To Expand Children's Health Insurance Program to Cover Low-Income Adults. In 2000, McCain missed the chance to cast the deciding vote on an amendment that would have reduced $150 billion in tax relief by $11.2 billion over 5 years in order to increase total Federal spending by that amount to expand the Children's Health Insurance Program to cover adults as well as children. (In 1997, Congress passed the CHIP program to pay for health insurance for children in lower-income families who don't qualify for Medicaid.) The amendment failed 49-49. [SCR 101, Vote #78, 4/7/00]
McCain Voted Against Increasing Cigarette Taxes To Provide Funding For Children's Health Insurance Programs. In 1997, McCain voted against an amendment to increase the excise tax on cigarettes by 43 cents per pack to provide $12 billion for children's health insurance programs through fiscal 2002. The amendment failed 30-70. [S 949, Vote #149, 6/27/97]
McCain Voted Against Increasing The Tobacco Tax To Provide Health Insurance To Low And Moderate Income Children. In 1997, McCain voted to table an amendment that would raise an additional $30 billion in revenue by increasing the tobacco tax. Of that, $20 billion would be used to provide health insurance for low- and moderate-income children. The motion to table passed 55-45. [SCR 27, Vote #76, 5/21/97]
McCain Voted Against Efforts To Crack Down On Violent Crime
McCain Voted Against The 1994 Crime Bill That Included Comprehensive Crime Prevention Measures. In 1994, Senator McCain voted against H.R. 3355, the Violent Crime Control and Enforcement Act. The legislation passed and was signed into law by President Clinton. [H.R. 3355, Vote #295, 8/25/1994]
- McCain Voted Against $3.94 Billion For Violent Offender Incarceration. Sections 20103 and 20109 of H.R. 3355 authorized $3.94 billion for Violent Offender Incarceration Grants for Fiscal Years 1995-2000. The legislation stipulated that funds be targeted to states with the greatest need and based on the number of violent crimes reported. [H.R. 3355, accessed 9/26/08]
- McCain Voted Against Anti-Crime Initiative For Rural Areas. USA Today reported that H.R. 3355 included "$245 million for rural anti-crime efforts." [USA Today, 8/29/94]
1996: McCain Voted Against Extending Violent Crime Reduction Trust Fund. In 1996, McCain voted against extending the Violent Crime Reduction Trust Fund by an additional two years. McCain cast the deciding vote. The motion to kill the amendment passed 51-49. [S.C.R. 57, Vote #123, 5/22/1996]
McCain Voted Against Efforts To Recruit New Police Officers & Put More Cops On The Streets
McCain Voted Against The 1994 Crime Bill That Included Measures To Increase The Number Of Police Officers On The Streets. In 1994, Senator McCain voted against H.R. 3355, the Violent Crime Control and Enforcement Act. The legislation passed and was signed into law by President Clinton. [H.R. 3355, Vote #295, 8/25/1994]
- McCain Voted Against Adding 100,000 Police Officers Nationwide. USA Today reported that H.R. 3355 included funding "to add 100,000 police officers nationwide for police patrols." [USA Today, 8/29/94]
- McCain Voted Against $100 Million For Police Officer Scholarships. USA Today reported that H.R. 3355 included "$100 million for college scholarships for future and current police officers." [USA Today, 8/29/94]
2006: McCain Voted Against $16.5 Billion in Funding for State and Local First Responders. In 2006, McCain voted against providing an additional $16.5 billion for state and local first responder grant programs to be paid for by reducing some of the Bush tax cuts for people making more than $1 million per year. Both Senators Obama and Clinton voted in favor of the funding. The motion failed 38-62. [H.R. 5441, Vote #197, 7/12/2006]
2005: McCain Voted Against Additional Law Enforcement Funding. In 2005, McCain voted against increasing funding for the Community Oriented Policing Services (COPS) program by $1 billion, the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children by $10 million, and the Office of Violence Against Women by $9 million. Both Senators Obama and Clinton voted in favor of the additional funding. The motion failed 41-56. [H.R. 2862, Vote #226, 9/13/2005]
2003: McCain Voted Against Increasing Spending on COPS Program by $1 Billion. In 2003, McCain voted against increasing spending on the Community-Oriented Policing Services programs by $1 billion in Fiscal Year 2004 and put $1 billion toward deficit reduction. The spending would be offset by a $2 billion reduction in tax cuts. The amendment failed 48-52. [SCR 23, Vote #78, 3/21/2003]
1999: McCain Skipped Close Vote to Extend COPS Program. In 1999, McCain skipped the vote on an amendment to extend the COPS program from Fiscal Year 2000 to Fiscal Year 2005 and authorize $1.15 billion annually for 2001-2005. The amendment would have authorized $600 million annually to fund up to 50,000 police officers, including hiring new officers. It also would have authorized $350 million annually for new law enforcement technology. The amendment failed 48-50. [S. 254, Vote #139, 5/20/1999]
1999: McCain Voted Against Extending COPS Program. In 1999, McCain voted against expanding the COPS program for two years to help hire 25,000 new police officers. The amendment also would have increased penalties for drug sales to children and for sales near schools, and increased penalties for transferring handguns and assault weapons to juveniles. The motion to kill the amendment passed 54-44. [S. 254, Vote #109, 5/12/1999]
1996: McCain Voted Against Cops on the Beat Program. In 1996, McCain voted against providing $1.8 billion for the Cops on the Beat program in Fiscal Year 1996. The program aimed to put 100,000 police officers on the street and was established by the Crime Control Act of 1994. The cost would be offset by reducing law enforcement block grants in the bill. The motion to kill the amendment passed 52-48. [H.R. 3019, Vote #31, 3/13/1996]
McCain Voted Against Efforts To Crack Down On Gangs
McCain Voted Against The 1994 Crime Bill That Included Measures To Crack Down On Gangs. In 1994, Senator McCain voted against H.R. 3355, the Violent Crime Control and Enforcement Act. The legislation passed and was signed into law by President Clinton. [H.R. 3355, Vote #295, 8/25/1994]
- McCain Voted Against Funding For "Safe Haven" After School Program For Kids. USA Today reported that H.R. 3355 included "$567 million for after-school, weekend and summer 'safe haven' programs for kids; and $243 million for in-school programs providing positive activities and alternatives to crime and drug abuse." [USA Today, 8/29/94]
- McCain Voted Against Anti-Gang Programs. USA Today reported that H.R. 3355 included "$377 million to be used for anti-gang programs, midnight sports leagues, boys and girls clubs and other projects." [USA Today, 8/29/94]
McCain Voted Against Funding for After-School Programs to Reduce Juvenile Crime. In 1999, McCain voted to table an amendment to authorize $600 million in each of FY 2000-2004 for after-school programs. The programs' goals included reducing juvenile crime, increasing academic success of students, promoting safe and productive environments for students, and providing alternatives to drugs, tobacco, and gangs. Motion to table agreed to 53-47. [S 254, Vote #132, 5/19/99]
McCain Voted Against Increasing Funding for After-School Programs. In 1999, McCain voted to kill an amendment that increased funding for the 21st Century Learning Center Program from $200 million to $600 million to help additional 1.1 million children participate in after-school and summer school programs. The funding would permit mentoring, academic assistance, drug, alcohol, and gang prevention programs to be funded through 21st Century Learning Center Program. Motion to table agreed to 55-44. [S 280, Vote #44, 3/11/99]
Governor Sarah Palin's Policies Hurt Alaska's Families
As Governor, Palin Stripped Over $1 Million In Funding For Seniors
Palin Personally Cut Nearly $250,000 For Seniors In S.B. 53:
| Amount Palin Cut | Purpose Of Funding Cut By Palin |
| $100,000 | AARP Ketchikan – Access Road for Ketchikan Senior Housing Project |
| $20,000 | Catholic Community Services - Angoon Senior Center Stove, Refrigerator, and Freezer |
| $15,000 | Kodiak Senior Center Facilities Repair and Equipment |
| $75,000 | Sterling Area Senior Center, Inc. (SASCI) - Sterling Senior Center Improvements |
| $39,000 | Wrangell - Medical Center 12-Passenger Handicapped Bus |
[S.B. 53 Vetoes via Legis.State.AK.us, accessed 9/1/08]
Palin Personally Cut More Than $1.16 Million For Seniors In S.B. 221:
| Amount Palin Cut | Purpose Of Funding Cut By Palin |
| $20,000 | Catholic Community Services - Angoon Senior Center Stove, Refrigerator and Freezer |
| $300,000 | Ketchikan Senior Citizens, Inc. - Access Road for Pioneer Heights |
| $50,000 | Alaska State Hospital & Nursing Home Association - Anchorage Medical Clinic Study |
| $20,000 | Alpha Omega Life Care, Inc. - Delivery Van and Moveable Building |
| $150,000 | Anchor - Age Center - Study of Future Needs |
| $50,000 | Homer Senior Citizens Senior Housing Land Purchase |
| $162,000 | Inuit Circumpolar Council Youth and Elder Program |
| $20,000 | Older Persons Action Group - Senior Voice Equipment Upgrade |
| $125,000 | Statewide Independent Living Centers - Assistive Technology for Alaska's Centers for Independent Living |
| $270,000 | Haines Senior Assisted Living Center for removal and disposal of the Alaskan and Proud buildings in Haines |
[S.B. 221 Vetoes via Legis.State.AK.us, accessed 9/9/08]
As Governor, Palin Stripped Nearly $4 Million For Programs For Women & Families
Palin Personally Cut $52,000 For Women & Families In S.B. 53
| Amount Palin Cut | Purpose Of Funding Cut By Palin |
| $52,000 | Salvation Army Alaska Division - Booth Memorial Youth and Family Services Facility Upgrade |
[S.B. 53 Vetoes via Legis.State.AK.us, accessed 9/1/08]
Palin Personally Cut More Than $3.71 Million For Women & Families In S.B. 221
| Amount Palin Cut | Purpose Of Funding Cut By Palin |
| $50,000 | Alaska Family Services, Inc - Vehicle, Fencing and Furniture for The New Behavioral Health Services Building |
| $150,000 | Catholic Community Resources - Fairbanks Counseling & Adoption |
| $3,500,000 | Cook Inlet Housing Authority - Workforce Development Student Housing and Day Care Facility Services |
| $15,840 | Resource Center for Parents and Children - Women, Infant, and Children (WIC) Program |
[S.B. 221 Vetoes via Legis.State.AK.us, accessed 9/9/08]
As Governor, Palin Stripped Over $100,000 For Victims' Programs
Palin Personally Cut $94,000 For Victims' Programs In S.B. 53
| Amount Palin Cut | Purpose Of Funding Cut By Palin |
| $50,000 | Victims for Justice - Program Support |
| $44,000 | Interior Alaska Center for Non-Violent Living - Facility Improvement Grant |
[S.B. 53 Vetoes via Legis.State.AK.us, accessed 9/1/08]
Palin Personally Cut $25,000 For Victims' Programs In S.B. 221
| Amount Palin Cut | Purpose Of Funding Cut By Palin |
| $25,000 | Victims Assistance Academy Establishment |
[S.B. 221 Vetoes via Legis.State.AK.us, accessed 9/9/08]
Governor Palin Stalled Health Care Reform
Palin's Hometown Paper Criticized Her For Stalling Health Care Reform. According to Think ProgressJP, "Five months ago, Gov. Sarah Palin's (R-AK) home town newspaper, the Anchorage Daily News, strongly criticized the governor for stalling comprehensive health care reform. The editorial argued that while Palin promised to 'tackle tough health care problems head-on' during her election bid, she failed to 'get behind the most significant piece of health legislation offered – a proposal to ensure that all residents have health insurance, without disrupting the coverage that many Alaskans already have.'" [Think Progress, 9/4/08]
Legislation Signed By Palin Maintained Eligibility Level For Children's Health Care That Kept Alaska Among Worst In The Nation. According to Think ProgressJP, "Palin also signed legislation updating Alaska's SCHIP program, Denali KidCare. SB-27 maintained the eligibility level-which had dropped to an effective rate of almost 150 percent of the poverty line due to inflation. However, by limiting eligibility to families living below 175 percent of the poverty line, Alaska's eligibility criteria are still among the lowest in the nation. Unfortunately, Palin did not support legislation to expand eligibility to higher levels." [Think Progress, 9/4/08]
- Palin Was Not Involved In 2007 Children's Health Care Debate. According to Think ProgressJP, "Indeed, a review of Palin's health care record suggests that Palin has done little to increase access to affordable coverage. During the national debate about expanding the State Children [sic] Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), for instance, Palin offered little leadership in comparison to her colleagues and failed to advocate for expanded children's coverage." [Think Progress, 9/4/08]